The myth of “too costly”
BY ROB KRAUSER
The Courier’s October 23, 1993 issue had an insert from the School Building Committee of that time on the process of deciding on building and renovation options for Cape schools. One option was to build two new schools for $16-$18 million. They passed on this, citing it being “too costly.”
Certain members of the current Cape community decry the only new building option the 2024 SBAC is still considering (Option E) as “too costly.” Looking at overall cost and tax percentage increase, it’s hard to argue with them.
But the real question is, what will the actual tax impact be on Cape residents?
Thankfully, the SBAC has provided that information, verified by Town Manager Matt Sturgis.
For a median value home in Cape, currently $700,000, the tax cost for Option E is $102 a month/$3.65 a day. $3.65 per day gets Cape a new MS which would last 60+ years, renovations to the ES and HS, and will require almost no disruption for students.
Option B, the cheapest option which is renovation/addition only, would cost $69 a month/ $2.47 a day. Option B would also mean 100% disruption for Cape students for up to three years (including possible bussing to schools outside of Cape). Those renovations would last 10-20 years, maximum.
The daily tax impact cost difference between Option E and Option B is $1.18.
Folks who still think option E is “too costly” either don’t have the facts or are willfully ignoring them.
In the news…
I had the privilege of co-chairing the School Building Advisory Committee. I wanted to be involved because I believe in the strength of public education, and wanted to roll up my sleeves and help address our school's needs…. [and] I am voting to support the school bond.
In 1973, we were blessed to move to Cape Elizabeth and find our first home on Cherry Circle. We raised our four children in Cape both as working parents… both of us are 80 years old and we know that we may not see the long-term investment of the school bond come to fruition.
I joined the SBAC to share my experience as an architect who has worked on 50+ school design projects.
The design process, led by our industry leading Architect and Owner's Project Manager, was meticulous and transparent.
The October 2, 2024 issue of The Cape Courier featured stories from Middle Ground supporters in the community. Did you find them all?
As a newcomer to Cape Elizabeth, I feel it’s important to share my experience with the last school bond vote. I’m a bit embarrassed to admit that I got duped by all the glossy mailers…
Jeffrey Shedd shares, "I voted AGAINST the last school buildings proposal. I will vote FOR the middle ground proposal.
I have been impressed with the process and communication throughout the latest planning work. Based on many visits to the middle school, I can say unequivocally: it’s a mess."
My support for the bond comes from my professional perspective, as someone who has spent 20 years in the commercial real estate industry, the last 16 spent as a developer in Portland. I thought I would share some of my insights here, because, as both a taxpayer and real estate developer, I’m impressed with the process and the resulting compromise proposal.
People from all perspectives (parents, grandparents, teachers, people with fixed incomes, and long-time Cape residents) spoke about how they had doubts during the last referendum and how their opinion on the need for a new school has evolved since then. Thanks to an inclusive and thoughtful planning process, our community can see and understand the need for a new middle school
As a former Maine Public School Educator and retired senior citizen of Cape Elizabeth, I implore all members of our voting community to urge our Town Council to put forward the Middle Ground School Building Project so we may vote in November to give our children the school facilities they so desperately require and deserve.
I am a 79 year old retiree, living in Cape Elizabeth 43 years; I wholeheartedly endorse Option E. Who are we as a community, if we abandon our children’s needs?
I think we can all agree that our children shouldn’t have to pay the price in our place. I consider myself very fortunate to live on a street and in a community where neighbors step up and take care of each other, during power outages, storms and everyday life.
The town should start saving now, in this year’s budget, for its infrastructure needs — like the schools. Also, we should establish infrastructure funds to save for our future needs, together with a sensible municipal bonding plan. Let’s put our values back in our budget.